Agnes Aubert's Mystical Cat Shelter by Heather Fawcett

Title: Agnes Aubert's Mystical Cat Shelter

Author: Heather Fawcett

Genre: Cosy Fantasy

Series: N/A

368 pages, Hardcover

Publication: February 17, 2026

Source: Personal Library

Buy|AMAZON|

Agnes Aubert leads a meticulously organized life, and she likes it that way. As the proudly type-A manager of a cat rescue charity, she has devoted her life to finding forever homes for stray cats.

Now it’s the shelter that needs a new home. And the only landlord who will rent a space to a cat rescue is a mysterious man called Havelock—who also happens to be the world’s most infamous magician, running an illegal magic shop out of his basement. Havelock is cantankerous and eccentric, but not not handsome, and no, Agnes absolutely does not feel anything but disdain for him. After all, rumors swirl about his shadowy past—including whispers that his dark magic once almost brought about the apocalypse.

Then one day a glamorous magician comes looking for Havelock, putting the magic shop—and the cat shelter—in jeopardy. To save the shelter, Agnes will have to team up with the magician who nearly ended the world . . . and may now be trying to steal her heart.

Havelock is everything Agnes thinks she doesn’t need in her life: chaos, mischief, and a little too much adventure. But as she gets to know him, she discovers that he’s more than the dark magician of legend, and that she may be ready for a little intrigue—and romance—in her life. After all, second chances aren’t just for rescue cats. . . .

MY THOUGHTS

It took me an extremely long time to get into the story. All I had been hearing about this book was how cute and cozy it was. I found it to be neither.

I didn’t find the plot as charming as I had hoped; instead, it felt more tiresome. The FMC, Agnes, is desperately trying to relocate her cat shelter and ends up renting from a notorious magician. For the majority of the book, Agnes is setting up her shelter(s) while helping Havelock, the magician, search for an unknown magical artifact, all while getting attacked by his sister and her cronies. The plot itself wasn’t exciting at all, and the pacing was equivalent to watching paint dry.

I felt zero connection with the characters. I found Agnes and her sister terribly irritating. At the start of the book, Agnes is portrayed as someone who is mostly quiet, follows the rules, and maybe is even a bit meek. But once she comes face to face with the apparently big, bad, scary magician Havelock, she suddenly develops a new personality; someone who not only talks back but also snoops around and inserts herself into people’s business like she has every right to.

Then there’s Havelock, who turns out not to be a big, bad, scary magician at all but just a curious, nerdy guy with magic. He gives off the awkward recluse type. I hated the way he spoke; it felt like he was trying too hard to sound indifferent. As one can guess, Agnes and Havelock are paired together, but there was absolutely no chemistry whatsoever. It also came out of nowhere and felt unrealistic.

The book was initially teetering around almost three stars because it had its moments, but once the author inserted the time travel around the 80% mark, it dropped for me. I didn’t like that twist; it felt like a cheap and easy solution to solving all their problems. How convenient that Agnes suddenly finds what she needs at the very last moment and how convenient that it happens to do exactly what she needs: travel back in time to retrieve the one object required to save everyone.

I understand cozy books are meant to be low stakes and low reward, but even this felt subpar. The plot was so thin, and the characters were barely tolerable. I’m honestly wondering why this book was even written. There weren’t any key takeaways or morals to the story that I noticed (and sure, maybe there weren’t supposed to be). Cozy books are supposed to be sweet, fun, or comforting and I didn’t get any of that.

I don’t understand all the hype around this book, but that’s okay. The book wasn't necessarily bad, but it wasn't good either.

The Dark Hiss of Magic by Helen Harper

Title: The Dark Hiss of Magic

Author: Helen Harper

Genre: Urban Fantasy

Series: The Cat Lady Chronicles # 2

286 pages, Paperback

Publication: June 16, 2025

Source: Personal Library

Buy|AMAZON|

When Kit rescues a wealthy witch from the treacherous, monster-filled waters of the River Tweed, she reckons she's completed her fair share of good deeds for the day. But when a second anonymous body is pulled from the same river, Kit is dragged into a mystery as murky as the water itself. The corpse has no identification, no personal possessions and no one who cares. Kit is determined to change that.

At least Thane Barrow, the copper-haired werewolf who sees the world in a similar way to Kit, is happy to also get involved. Together, they navigate Coldstream’s magical streets and mysterious secrets, determined to uncover the truth about John Doe. Alas, it soon becomes clear that his death was no accident. Kit finds herself investigating a complex crime with more than one victim. She will have her claws full if she's going to get to the bottom of what's happened.

One thing is for certain - when death threatens, Kit McCafferty doesn’t back down. She pounces.

MY THOUGHTS

I just finished the first book in the Cat Lady Chronicles and had high hopes for this series; thus, me jumping straight into the second book. In the sequel, The Dark Hiss of Magic, we find Kit getting herself entangled in a murder mystery and, once again, with the help of Thane, the lone werewolf, they take it upon themselves to solve the crime of a John Doe.

I think I spoke too soon because the story started to fizzle out early on, and I found myself not as invested or interested as I was in the first book. As I've said before, I love the Urban Fantasy genre, but there was nothing in book two that held my attention. The plot was generic, and I didn't really like that Kit thought it was her duty to find out the identity of John Doe and eventually track down his murderer. It felt like she had nothing better to do with her life than insert herself into an investigation (or lack thereof if she didn’t take the initiative). The point is, I didn’t find myself caring.

Also, in my last review of the first book, I mentioned what I hoped would happen. I was hoping for a possible love interest in the werewolf Alpha, but this book answered that pretty quickly. After seeing it would come to nothing and realizing who the werewolf’s real love interest was, I already had one foot out the door, to be honest. I love good tension and banter between a leading couple, and I certainly don’t see it with Kit and Thane. There is no chemistry, and their “romance” feels too obvious and easy, which isn’t my thing.

The plot was pretty thin this time around. I didn’t particularly like the portrayal of vampires and witches in this book either. What I noticed while reading the second book is that the supernatural community isn’t scary or interesting. If we weren’t told that X, Y, or Z person was a witch, werewolf, or fae, you’d think you were just reading a regular contemporary, cozy, or murder mystery with regular humans.

With that said, I will no longer be continuing the series.

Waifs and Strays by Helen Harper

Title: Waifs and Strays

Author: Helen Harper

Genre: Urban Fantasy

Series: The Cat Lady Chronicles # 1

298 pages, Paperback

Publication: February 10, 2025

Source: Personal Library

Buy|AMAZON|

Nobody is just a cat lady.

Kit McCafferty's life is quiet, unremarkable and filled with cat hair. In the magical city of Coldstream, located on the border between Scotland and England, Kit is viewed as little more than mildly eccentric and mostly harmless. She passes her days caring for her family of five cats, feeding the local feral moggies, and maintaining relatively good relations with her neighbours.

All that changes, however, when a teenage werewolf shows up at her door in the desperate hope of renting out a nearby vacant flat. Kit knows that the smart move is to tell him to leave. The last thing she needs is to become embroiled in complicated shapeshifter politics. But something about the secretive young werewolf tugs at her heartstrings.

It's not long before Kit ends up caught in a maelstrom of mysterious crime and magical wrong-doing. Fortunately, there's far more to Kit McCafferty than meets the eye and she has a few dark secrets of her own.

Of course, anyone with an ounce of intelligence knows that you underestimate a cat lady at your own peril.

MY THOUGHTS

I stumbled upon Waifs and Strays during one of those free eBook days. I loved the cover, it felt playful and the synopsis was interesting enough. Plus, I’m always looking for a good Urban Fantasy. It’s not every day that I find an Urban Fantasy set in the UK or one featuring a heroine in her forties, which piqued my interest even more.

The beginning of the book took a little getting used to. As the title and series name suggest, there are a lot of cats in the story. However, their names are pretty unconventional. They play a significant role, and as the book progressed, I did get used to their unique naming style. The worldbuilding is straightforward: it’s an open world where supernaturals are known to the public. Coldstream, where Kit lives, is mostly inhabited by magical folk like fae, vampires, werewolves, and all sorts of other creatures.

At first glance, Kit is known around the neighborhood as the innocuous, middle-aged cat lady. She’s anything but simple, as we eventually discover. Kit was a likable heroine. I enjoyed learning about her past profession and magical abilities and seeing them come into play when a young werewolf is abducted. She’s essentially the local superhero or maybe vigilante, despite trying to live a quiet, normal life. I also liked what I assume will become the supporting cast, though it’s still too early to tell. Is it weird that I’m hoping for a love triangle between Thane and the Alpha? Lol.

I thought Waifs and Strays was a great introduction to The Cat Lady Chronicles. The pacing was solid, and the book was well written. Overall, I was pleasantly surprised by how much I ended up enjoying it. I’m about to start the second book, the series feels promising.