Witch of the Wolves by Kaylee Archer

Title: Witch of the Wolves

Author: Kaylee Archer

Genre: Fantasy

Series: Witch of the Wolves # 1

Publication: September 30, 2025

352 pages

Source: Libby Library

Buy|AMAZON|B&N

Cordelia Levine comes from a long line of powerful witches. She's been flying under the radar in the human world, focused on strengthening her magic. She loves working at her aunt's apothecary in London, secretly serving supernaturals.

Until the truth about her family is revealed.

She always assumed her enhanced sense of smell came from her French perfumer father. But when Bishop Daniels abducts Cordelia at the request of her father, the Alpha, Cordelia learns she's a lycan--sharing both witch and werewolf traits. She's brought to Trevelyan, the pack estate, under the guise of protection from foreign threats who want to use her to continue their bloodline.

She quickly learns that to keep her from being sold off to another pack, her father intends to give Cordelia as a mate to Bishop. His second in command and the future Alpha.

Cordelia refuses to accept this as her fate. She can't rely on her magic alone to escape and when she learns Bishop plans to challenge her father's power, she reluctantly begins to trust him. The cracks within the Pack become evident and something is bound to break. And Cordelia and her growing desire for the man who shouldn't set her on fire are right at the center of it all.

MY THOUGHTS

Witch of the Wolves was one of my most anticipated reads this year. I’ve been looking forward to it ever since I first heard about it. A Victorian setting and supernatural creatures? That’s right up my alley, two of my favorite things combined! The book started off strong, and I was immediately immersed in the story. I honestly thought it would pull me out of my disappointing reading streak because it had so much potential. Unfortunately, it hit a snag halfway through and never fully recovered.

The worldbuilding and magic system were promising at first but ultimately built like a house of cards; weak at the foundation and barely held together by hope and readers' obliviousness. There’s almost no explanation of how werewolves are made or how their transformations work, aside from a vague mention that it’s painful. It feels like the author expected readers to fill in the blanks rather than creating her own lore. The witches fare no better; their spells are given the most unimaginative names possible: knockback, fireball, privacy, and fog, which sound just as lame as they read. The worldbuilding overall was poorly executed. Although the synopsis claims a Victorian setting, the only indication of the Victorian Era were Cordelia’s wardrobe and the period-typical gender dynamics, where, unsurprisingly, most women are relegated to subservient roles.

I actually liked Cordelia at first, but halfway through, right around the time she got involved with Bishop, she turned into a naive, immature child. The insta-love/lust between them was unrealistic; they barely knew each other for a week before falling all over each other. Throughout the book, Cordelia verbally fights her arranged marriage to Bishop but when the day arrives, she immediately accepts it. Then when a family member is killed, the natural reaction would be rage or grief right? What does she do? Rolls into bed with Bishop like the person wasn't killed less than an hour ago. Sure, we get one paragraph afterwards of her crying but the whole situation gets swept over like it never happened.

We’re constantly told how special Cordelia is, “the first of her kind,” a witch and a Lycan whom everyone covets for her power or bloodline. But despite being hyped up as immensely powerful, she barely uses her magic. Most of the time, it sputters out. Near the end, she kills a single person and suddenly everyone gasps, “Oh my god, she’s more powerful than we imagined!” Give me a break. It was lazy and anticlimactic. She never steps up when it truly matters. Bishop wasn’t much better. He falls into lust at first sight the moment he sees Cordelia and spends the rest of the book making promises he never actually keeps while acting all bashful about how she tests his ability to “remain a gentleman.” He’s supposed to be Alpha material, but he never once gave that impression. By the halfway point, I’d stopped caring about either of them or the outcome of their story.

The plot itself was equally disappointing. It boiled down to petty, repetitive family drama that went nowhere. You know those endless arguments where everyone insists, they’re right and nothing gets resolved? That’s this book in a nutshell. Cordelia’s father has beef with her mother and aunt, Bishop’s family has beef with Cordelia’s father, and her grandmother has beef with everyone and the pack. I didn’t pick this up to read about childish family squabbles. The only characters who held my attention were Bishop’s inner circle and a mute little girl who had minimal dialogue or page time. Nuff said.

In the end, I do not recommend Witch of the Wolves. I’m just glad I borrowed it from the library instead of buying it.